Editor Charles Mackay introduces this collection by contrasting the political function of seventeenth-century ballads with the diminished role of song in his own day. He asserts that the Cavalier ballads, like the later Jacobite ones, are 'mines of wealth' for studying history and social manners, serving as a medium that reached the masses when print was limited to the educated. Mackay laments that England and America have become 'too prosaic and too busy' for such poetry, reserving appreciation for Scotland and Ireland.

The excerpts include a lengthy comic ballad detailing a physical altercation between a vicar and a cobbler, mediated by a magistrate. The vicar famously declares he will remain Vicar of Bray 'whichever side prevails,' having taken oaths 'without remorse' as 'meerly things of course.' The cobbler accuses him of being willing to 'swear to Turk or Pope' to keep his living. The fight escalates, drawing in a constable and a butcher, before the magistrate intervenes with drawn blade.

Mackay's Editorial Framing

Mackay's introduction positions the ballads as historical documents rather than literary artifacts. He argues that in the seventeenth century, when the printing press served only the educated minority, songs and ballads 'appealed to the passion, if not to the intellect of the masses' and instructed them in current events. This function, he claims, has been supplanted by the daily press. Mackay is sharply critical of contemporary popular taste, dismissing 'Negro Minstrelsy' and sentimental love songs as vulgar, while elevating Thomas Moore and Robert Burns as writers whose elegance and force are 'above the sphere' of the masses. This editorial voice—confident, nostalgic, and class-conscious—shapes how the reader encounters the ballads.

The Vicar of Bray Motif

The excerpted ballad centers on a vicar who openly admits to adapting his oaths to the ruling power: 'I’ll still obey the State' and 'I can take the Covenant / And never hang an ass.' This is a direct reference to the historical figure Simon Aleyn, the Vicar of Bray, who changed his religious allegiance to match the monarch. The ballad uses this figure to satirize clerical opportunism during the Civil War and Commonwealth periods. The cobbler, representing a more principled commoner, denounces the vicar as a 'hopeful priest' who would 'for gain he would his God deny, / His country and his King.' The physical fight that follows literalizes the ideological conflict between steadfastness and self-serving flexibility.

Physical Comedy and Social Hierarchy

The ballad employs broad physical humor: the vicar strikes the cobbler with his 'sacerdotal fist,' the cobbler returns blows 'with both head and heel,' and the constable seizes the vicar 'by the throat.' The magistrate enters with a 'naked blade,' threatening 'the vengeance of the State.' Yet the humor undercuts authority—the vicar is throttled, the cobbler fights back, and a butcher intervenes. The poem's structure, with its rapid dialogue and escalating violence, mirrors the chaotic factionalism of the period. Mackay's inclusion of such a piece illustrates his claim that these ballads were 'effective' for the Cavalier cause, using ridicule and rowdy narrative to engage listeners.

Readers should note that Mackay's editorial stance is itself a historical artifact, revealing Victorian attitudes toward popular culture and political poetry. The ballads are presented as evidence of a lost public sphere where song carried political weight. As you read, consider how the humor, dialect, and recurring figures—the Vicar of Bray, the cobbler, the magistrate—encode specific partisan positions. The collection rewards attention to the interplay between Mackay's framing and the raw, often irreverent voices of the ballads themselves.